Best Ice Maker in 2026: 7 Countertop Picks for Every Kind of Ice

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, Voralist may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Prices checked November 2026.

If your freezer ice maker is slow, broken, or just cannot keep up with iced coffee season, a countertop ice maker fixes it for roughly the price of a decent blender. For most people, the Frigidaire EFIC189 is the one to buy: 26 pounds of bullet ice a day, first batch in about 6 minutes, around $79. If what you really want is soft, chewable nugget ice, skip straight to the GE Profile Opal 2.0, or save money with the EUHOMY Nugget. Everything below is based on maker specs, published tests, and what owners complain about after a few months of use. One warning up front: the cleaning routine matters more than the brand.

Quick Comparison

PickIce typeOutputFirst batchSelf-cleaningPrice
Frigidaire EFIC189Bullet26 lbs/dayAbout 6 minYesAbout $79
Silonn SLIM01BBullet26 lbs/day6 minYesSee price on Amazon
GE Profile Opal 2.0 XLNugget38 lbs/dayAbout 10 minYes, cleaning cycle$549
EUHOMY Nugget (IM-12S-HM)Nugget34 lbs/day6 to 8 minYesAbout $104
NewAir ClearIce40Clear cubes40 lbs/dayUnder 15 minNoAbout $256 to $280
EUHOMY Countertop (IM-06D-HM)Bullet26 lbs/day6 minYes, auto-cleaningSee price on Amazon
Igloo IGLICEB26HNBKBullet26 lbs/day6 to 8 minYesAbout $85

1. Frigidaire EFIC189: best ice maker for most people

Frigidaire EFIC189 countertop ice maker

Bullet | 26 lbs/day | About 6 min first batch | Self-cleaning | About $79

The EFIC189 is the default recommendation in this category for a boring reason: it has been sold for years, the owner base is huge, and the formula works. It makes bullet ice in two sizes, up to 26 pounds a day, first batch in about 6 minutes. There is a self-cleaning cycle, a see-through lid, and a price near $79 at the time of checking, which undercuts most name-brand rivals.

Pros

  • Fast first batch and steady output for daily family use
  • Two bullet sizes, and the small ones chill drinks quickly
  • Self-cleaning cycle, which most budget rivals at this price skip

Cons

  • The basket is insulated, not refrigerated, so ice slowly melts and gets recycled. Output numbers assume you keep using or bagging the ice
  • Owners report the ice-full sensor occasionally stopping production early until the basket is nudged
  • Durability is mixed in owner reviews, with some units slowing down after a year of heavy use

Check Price on Amazon

2. Silonn SLIM01B: best budget ice maker

Silonn SLIM01B countertop ice maker

Bullet | 26 lbs/day | 6 min first batch | Self-cleaning | See price on Amazon

The Silonn is one of the best-selling countertop ice makers on Amazon, and the pitch is simple: 9 bullet cubes in 6 minutes, 26 pounds a day, two cube sizes, a self-cleaning function, and a price that usually lands well under the Frigidaire. Controls are three buttons and indicator lights. There is almost nothing to learn, which is what most buyers want here. If the budget is the whole decision, our cheap coffee maker guide follows the same logic on the coffee side: spend less, accept the trade offs, and know them before you buy.

Pros

  • Among the fastest first batches in the budget class
  • Self-cleaning function at a budget price
  • Quiet for a compressor machine, and small enough for an office or dorm

Cons

  • Durability is the recurring complaint. A noticeable share of owners report breakdowns within the first several months
  • Small bullets melt fast in the basket and in the glass
  • The water tank is small, so party use means refills

Check Price on Amazon

3. GE Profile Opal 2.0: best nugget ice maker

GE Profile Opal 2.0 nugget ice maker

Nugget | 38 lbs/day | About 10 min first batch | Cleaning cycle | $549

Nugget ice is the soft, chewable, Sonic-style ice people get oddly passionate about, and the Opal 2.0 still defines the category. It produces up to 38 pounds a day, first nuggets in around 10 minutes, and the XL side tank holds a gallon of water, so refills are rare. It connects to the SmartHQ app for scheduling, and the bin holds about 3 pounds. It is also big, nearly 40 pounds, and priced at $549, which buys six Frigidaires. Published measurements put it near 51 dB in use, so you will hear it across a quiet kitchen.

Pros

  • The best nugget texture in a countertop machine, full stop
  • High output and a big side tank for households that go through ice all day
  • App scheduling, so ice is ready when you get home

Cons

  • The price, and the counter space. At 17.5 inches deep it dominates a small kitchen
  • Nugget machines are the most cleaning-sensitive type you can buy, and the Opal wants a weekly routine
  • Some owners report support and parts frustration once the warranty ends

Check Price on Amazon

4. EUHOMY Nugget (IM-12S-HM): best nugget ice maker for less

EUHOMY Nugget IM-12S-HM ice maker

Nugget | 34 lbs/day | 6 to 8 min first batch | Auto-cleaning | About $104

If the Opal price made you flinch, this is the compromise most people land on. EUHOMY’s nugget machine makes up to 34 pounds of chewable pellet ice a day, first batch in 6 to 8 minutes, with auto-cleaning, a carry handle, and a removable top cover that makes the inside easier to wipe down than most nugget machines. It has well over 16,000 Amazon ratings. Expect to pay around $104, roughly a fifth of the Opal. Pair it with iced lattes and cold foam from our best milk frother guide and the nugget texture finally makes sense at home.

Pros

  • Real nugget ice at a bullet-machine budget
  • Auto-cleaning, and the removable lid helps with the scrubbing nugget machines need
  • Handle and modest footprint make it genuinely portable

Cons

  • Nuggets come out softer, melt faster than the Opal’s, and clump in the basket
  • The basket holds only about 1.8 pounds, so heavy use means bagging ice into the freezer
  • Skipping the cleaning cycle shows up fast as off-tasting ice, owners warn

Check Price on Amazon

5. NewAir ClearIce40: best clear ice for cocktails

NewAir ClearIce40 clear ice maker

Clear cubes | 40 lbs/day | Under 15 min first batch | No self-cleaning | About $256 to $280

Bullet and nugget ice are cloudy because air gets trapped as water freezes from the outside in. The ClearIce40 freezes water in layers over a chilled tray, pushing the air out to produce dense, clear cubes that melt slowly and look like bar ice. It makes up to 40 pounds a day, first batch in under 15 minutes, with adjustable cube thickness. For whiskey and cocktails, it is the only machine here making the right kind of ice. Clear cubes also suit espresso poured over ice, which our best espresso machines under $500 guide covers.

Pros

  • Genuinely clear, slow-melting cubes from a countertop machine with no plumbing
  • Highest daily output here, with a big 11-cup tank
  • Simple two-button operation

Cons

  • Cubes come out as a connected sheet you break apart with the scoop, which testers consistently found annoying
  • No self-cleaning function, and it is loud, measured around 60 dB in one published test
  • Amazon stock comes and goes, so check who is actually selling it

Price: about $256 to $280. No buy link on this pick: we could not pin the NewAir ClearIce40 to a single verified Amazon listing, and Amazon stock comes and goes, so search “NewAir ClearIce40” on Amazon or buy direct from NewAir before buying.

6. EUHOMY Countertop (IM-06D-HM): easiest cleaning routine

EUHOMY Countertop IM-06D-HM ice maker

Bullet | 26 lbs/day | 6 min first batch | Auto-cleaning | See price on Amazon

This is EUHOMY’s bullet machine with a carry handle, and its headline feature is an auto-cleaning cycle you run with one button press. It makes 9 bullet cubes in 6 minutes and up to 26 pounds a day. Plenty of machines claim a self-cleaning function; this one pairs it with a design that drains and dries more easily than most, the unglamorous detail that decides whether a machine still tastes fine in month six.

Pros

  • One-press auto-cleaning cycle, and a layout that is simple to drain
  • Carry handle and a compact body, built to be moved
  • Same fast 6-minute first batch as the other 26 lb bullets

Cons

  • Same melting-basket limitation as every bullet machine here
  • Tap water leaves mineral buildup if you skip descaling, and owners can taste it
  • The scoop and basket feel cheap next to the Frigidaire

Check Price on Amazon

7. Igloo IGLICEB26HNBK: best portable pick with a handle

Igloo IGLICEB26HNBK portable ice maker

Bullet | 26 lbs/day | 6 to 8 min first batch | Self-cleaning | About $85

The one to throw in the car for tailgates, boats, and backyard parties: 26 pounds of bullet ice a day, 9 cubes in 6 to 8 minutes, two sizes, a five-cycle self-cleaning function, and an LED panel that reads well outdoors, for about $85. The catch is the 1-quart tank, which needs constant refills during a party. It is a cooler top-up machine, not a home’s only ice source, and some owners report the full-basket sensor stopping production early.

Check Price on Amazon

Bullet vs nugget vs clear ice: the honest version

Bullet ice is what cheap and mid-range machines make. It is fast, the machines are simple, and the hollow bullets chill drinks quickly. It also melts quickly and waters drinks down, and every bullet machine shares one weakness: an unrefrigerated basket. Pick bullet for family, cooler, or office ice where texture does not matter.

Nugget ice is compacted flaked ice: soft, chewable, and it soaks up drink flavor, which is why soda and iced tea drinkers love it. The machines cost more, use a complex auger system, and are the most prone to mold and slime if cleaning slips, because the internals stay damp and hard to reach. Pick nugget only if the texture is the whole point.

Clear ice is about dilution and looks. Dense, air-free cubes melt slowly, so a cocktail tastes the same at the end of the glass. Output per batch is slower and machines cost more. Pick clear where dilution matters.

Cleaning and descaling: the section that decides if your machine lives

Every countertop ice maker is a dark, damp box that handles food. Left alone, two things build up inside: mineral scale from hard water, which coats sensors and pumps and slows production, and biofilm, the slimy layer owners find on bin walls and around the waterline, often with mold spots. Brand cleaning guides agree: this is the normal end state of an uncleaned machine, not a defect.

A routine that works:

  1. Run the self-cleaning cycle weekly if you use the machine daily, with fresh water each time. Nugget machines need this most.
  2. Descale monthly in hard-water areas, with the maker’s descaler or a vinegar solution. Then run two plain-water cycles and throw that ice away.
  3. Wash the basket and scoop by hand in warm soapy water. Do not store the scoop inside the bin, and wash your hands before reaching in. Hands and dirty scoops are a documented contamination route.
  4. Leave the lid open and let the machine dry fully whenever it will sit unused for more than a day. A closed, wet machine is where slime starts.
  5. Use filtered water if your tap water tastes of chlorine or leaves heavy scale. It improves taste and stretches the time between descaling.

If you already see slime or smell a musty odor, stop using the ice, run a full cleaning and sanitizing cycle per the manual, and discard the next two batches.

Mistakes people make with countertop ice makers

  • Treating the basket as a freezer. It is insulated, not refrigerated, and the “26 lbs a day” figure assumes you keep emptying it. That figure is also a 24-hour rating in ideal conditions; a warm kitchen cuts it noticeably.
  • Never descaling. Scale is the top reason these machines slow down and get blamed for breaking.
  • Buying nugget for a household that will not clean it. Nugget machines punish skipped cleaning faster than any other type.
  • Ignoring the sensors. Ice-full and add-water sensors are the most common failure point across brands. Keep the sensor window clean and do not fill past the max line.
  • Leaving water sitting in the tank for a week. Stagnant water is where the taste and slime come from. Drain it if the machine will sit.

For readers comparing counter appliances, our best drip coffee makers guide covers the other machine that lives on the same counter.

FAQ

How much ice does a countertop ice maker really make in a day?

The rating on the box, 26 to 40 pounds, means a full 24 hours of continuous production in good conditions. In a real kitchen, expect roughly two-thirds of that, and the basket only holds 1.5 to 3 pounds at a time.

Do countertop ice makers keep ice frozen?

No. The basket is insulated but not refrigerated, so ice slowly melts and the meltwater gets recycled into new ice. For parties, bag finished ice into the freezer as the basket fills.

Why does my ice taste bad or smell musty?

Almost always buildup: mineral scale, biofilm, or both. Run the cleaning cycle, descale, wash the basket and scoop, and switch to filtered water. If slime is visible, sanitize per the manual and discard the next two batches.

Is nugget ice worth the extra money?

Only if you chew ice or drink a lot of soda, iced tea, or iced coffee and texture matters to you. For parties and coolers, a $79 bullet machine does the same job for a fifth of the Opal’s price.

How often should I clean a countertop ice maker?

Weekly cleaning cycles for daily use, descaling about monthly, more often with hard water. GE recommends weekly cleaning for nugget machines specifically. Skipping this is the main reason these machines develop mold.

Can I leave my ice maker running all the time?

You can, but it uses power remaking melted ice around the clock. Switching it on a few hours before you need ice is cheaper, and draining it during gaps of several days prevents stale water problems.

Verdict

Buy the Frigidaire EFIC189 unless you have a specific reason not to: fast, cheap, self-cleaning, proven over years of sales. Buy the Silonn if the budget is firm and you accept a durability gamble. Buy the GE Profile Opal 2.0 if nugget ice is a daily pleasure and you will keep up the weekly cleaning, or the EUHOMY Nugget for most of that experience at about $104. Buy the NewAir ClearIce40 if you make cocktails and dilution matters. And whichever one lands on your counter, put the cleaning cycle on your calendar the day it arrives. That habit, not the brand, separates happy owners from the ones posting photos of slime. For every style side by side, start with our best coffee maker machines pillar.

Leave a Comment